Abortion pills: The Justice Department appealed a Texas judges decision that would block approval of the abortion pill mifepristone. Five smiling children, ages 6 through 15 and then Tyndale, on the end, stillborn. [9] On December 13, 2017, a hearing on his nomination was held before the Senate Judiciary Committee. Kacsmaryk, appointed to the federal bench by former President Donald Trump, is presiding over a challenge to the Food and Drug Administration's approval of mifepristone, one of two drugs used to terminate a pregnancy before 10 weeks gestation. But he made time for Christian Homes the only board he served on at the time of his nomination to the federal bench. She added that a contentious Kacsmaryk ruling would fall more heavily on certain people. In the fall of 2000, after Griffith gave birth, Kacsmaryk returned to law school at the University of Texas and focused his attention on the legal foundations for abortion rights. April 7, 2023. He wanted to talk. [25][20][26] He received his judicial commission on June 21, 2019. Trump Judge Matthew Kacsmaryk couldn't handle criticism, so he mocked Here's how to get it. Judicial Milestones. v. Phillips, 22 F.4th 512, 52021 (5th Cir. Whatever the result, an appeal is widely expected. The Court "heavily disfavor[s] sealing information placed in the judicial record"and discourages such requests. Let us pray, said one of Kacsmaryks clerks as the judge bowed his head. 2021). Kacsmaryk didnt see them. Same-sex relationships were disordered and contrary to natural law, he opined, basing his claims on the Catholic catechism. They called on the judge to immediately docket notice of the hearing, promptly . They consider, Where might we have a venue that maximizes the chances of victory?. Hes very passionate about the fact that you cant preach pro-life and do nothing, said Kacsmaryks sister, Jennifer Griffith. [21] His nomination was sent to the Senate later that day. But Kacsmaryk had a deep passion for religious freedom, Sasser said. [2] He graduated from Abilene Christian University in 1999 with a Bachelor of Arts, summa cum laude. Phone: 662-728-4611. James Byrd Jr. He was in Abilene to support his sister, who, pregnant at 17, had fled to a faraway maternity home to avoid the scorn she feared from their Christian community. Docket Report This docket was last retrieved on April 7, 2023. Standard of Dress Pursuant to LR 83.16 and LCrR 53.2. Judge says DPS must release documents related to Uvalde shooting response. U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas. The records could provide further . Here is what's at stake in abortion medication case | KTLA When Kacsmaryk appeared before the Senate in 2017, he vowed to be fair. Thats what good lawyers do, said Severino at the Heritage Foundation. The Supreme Court decided to retain full access to mifepristone as the appeal proceeds. On Friday, federal judge Matthew J. Kacsmaryk granted a preliminary injunction that could remove mifepristone, better known as the abortion pill, from the . To learn about Kacsmaryks life, Caroline and Ann traveled to Amarillo and Abilene, two cities where he has lived in west Texas. [54] Federal law only allows for such redactions when the public disclosure of information could "endanger" a judge or their family, and legal experts described Kacsmaryk's redaction as irregular and suggesting a potential conflict. Nevertheless, many far-flung lawyers and plaintiffs decide to make the journey. He was outspoken about his conservative beliefs from the start, several friends and professors recalled. On the 17 different campaigns listed, Kacsmaryk said he helped with rallies, made calls and participated in get-out-the-vote efforts. Kacsmaryk's delay in handing down his his widely-expected decision to nix FDA approval of mifepristone already raised eyebrows. Judge Kacsmaryk's Courtroom. Servs. 18th Chancery of Mississippi - Chancery Courts for Mississippi 18th Julie Marie Blake, senior counsel at the firm representing the Alliance for Hippocratic Medicine, said the groups decision to incorporate in Texas predates the abortion pills lawsuit. Court: Fifth Circuit Mississippi US District Court for the Southern District of Mississippi. Kacsmaryk commented to CNN that the redaction was reviewed and approved by the Administrative Office of the United States Courts, and that the company has never had business before his district's court. The J. Marvin Jones Federal Building and Mary Lou Robinson United States Courthouse in Amarillo, Texas, where U.S. District Judge Matthew Kacsmaryk will decide on a lawsuit over the abortion drug . Vladeck explained that conservative plaintiffs deciding where to lodge high-profile cases have 94 federal district courts to choose from. Circuit Clerk. Copy editing by Mina Haq. Despite such an overwhelming scientific scorecard, the conservative plaintiffs claim that a ban would protect the health, safety and welfare of all Americans by rejecting or limiting the use of dangerous drugs. Judge Matthew Kacsmaryk has amassed a litany of contentious rulings in less than four years. The Democratic Partys ability to condone the federally sanctioned eradication of innocent human life is indicative of the moral ambivalence undergirding this party, Kacsmaryk wrote, endorsing a Republican Party platform that would grant a fetus the full legal protections of a person. The Texas Department of Public Safety must release records related to last year's deadly Uvalde elementary school shooting, a district court judge in Austin ruled Thursday.. District court judge . It gave experience to something that had been probably a lot more academic, said Christian. On Friday, federal Judge Matthew Kacsmaryk held a conference call with the lawyers involved in the case that could result in a national ban of the abortion drug mifepristone. Circuit Clerk | Prentiss County A federal judge denied the Justice Department's attempt to keep secret the list of 84 potential witnesses with whom former President Donald Trump is barred from . The judge has decided to suspend the ruling for seven days, giving the Justice Department time to appeal the decision, which leaves the drug available on the market for the time being. A lawyer for the news outlets told U.S. District Judge Matthew Kacsmaryk that his attempt to withhold public notice of the hearing set for Wednesday, which limits the ability of the press and public to attend, is unconstitutional and "undermines the important values served by public access to judicial proceedings and court records. Position: U.S. District Judge. Aug. 1, 2017). She started working with anti-abortion crisis pregnancy centers. [46] The Washington Post described that Kacsmaryk's ruling repeatedly cites data collected from researchers affiliated with the anti-abortion Charlotte Lozier Institute, and also "cites research based on anonymous blog posts, cherry picks statistics that exaggerate the negative physical and psychological effects of mifepristone, and ignores hundreds of scientific studies attesting to the medication's safety. As Vladeck pointed out, there is an added bonus for any rightwing plaintiff coming to Amarillo: what happens to Kacsmaryks cases if they are appealed, as is almost certainly the case given their contentious nature. In his 2020 and 2021 annual disclosures, Judge Matthew Kacsmaryk wrote that he held between $5 million and $25 million in "common stock" of a company - a significant majority of the judge . His mother, Dorothy, was a microbiologist; Kacsmaryk's sister, Griffith, recalled that she chose to stay home with her children and was passionate about anti-abortion issues. 2022). Judge rules in favor of news outlets vs. DPS in suit over Uvalde records In December, Kacsmaryk sided with a Christian father who did not want his daughters to access birth control without his permission, challenging a federal program that provides low-cost or free contraception, including to teens without parental consent. PO Box 727. Family Planning & Preventative Health Servs., Inc. v. Kaufman, No. [48], On April 13, 2023, a three-judge panel of the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit granted an emergency stay on Kacsmaryk's restriction on the 2000 approval of mifepristone due to timeliness issues, stating that "it appears that the statute of limitations bars plaintiffs' challenges" to the 2000 approval; however, the panel, in a 2-1 vote, approved Kacsmaryk's restrictions on the FDA's actions expanding access to mifepristone from 2016. Alliance for Hippocratic Medicine et al v. U.S. Food and Drug Type: Contract Insurance. Supreme Court decided to retain full access to mifepristone, explanation of what happens next in the abortion pill case, women who had secret abortions before Roe v. Wade, seeking abortions while living in states with strict abortion bans, photos and stories from across America since the reversal of. Courtesy of Senate Judiciary Committee. The Texas Department of Public Safety has been ordered to release records on the Uvalde school shooting by a state district judge. I knew immediately he was thinking about the work our ministry does all the time outside of board meetings, said Statler. State of Texas v. Mayorkas, 2:22-cv-00094 - CourtListener.com Photo editing by Natalia Jimenez. Yet the group has lodged its challenge to the FDAs approval of mifepristone with Kacsmaryk. [53] A timeline Kacsmaryk submitted to the Senate Judiciary Committee stated that he was under consideration for a judicial nomination by early March and throughout April, meeting with Texas Senators Ted Cruz and John Cornyn, as well as White House Counsel. Fri 10 Feb 2023 02.00 EST Last modified on Fri 10 Feb 2023 09.35 EST M atthew Kacsmaryk, a federal judge in Texas appointed by Donald Trump, has a tendency to attract strong language. The Post is tracking states where abortion is legal, banned or under threat. Heres how it works. The lawsuit targeting the abortion pill was filed in November by the Alliance Defending Freedom, a conservative legal organization, on behalf of anti-abortion medical associations. According to the newspaper, Kacsmaryks anti-abortionbeliefs were ingrained when he was a 22-year-old law student and one of his sisters, 17, became pregnant and chose adoption over abortion. But, he said, the issue didnt become real for Kacsmaryk and his wife until 2006, when they lost their first baby at birth, a daughter they named Tyndale. God save the United States and this honorable court.. [17][18] He has worked on cases opposing certain LGBT protections in housing, employment, and health care. Late on Friday, the Biden administration filed its notice of appeal to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, which is considered one of the most conservative in the country. These dangerous drugs should never have been allowed on the market.. [4][6] Reuters described Kacsmaryk as a "one-time Christian activist", noting that First Liberty Institute is "a Christian conservative legal group that pursues religious-liberty cases". The 5th Circuit upheld Kacsmaryks decision, but the Supreme Court reversed it in June, saying Biden had the right to end the program. They called on the judge to immediately docket notice of the hearing, promptly disclose future proceedings in the case and release the lawyers involved in the legal fight from his request not to discuss the hearing schedule publicly. Im in the role of reading and applying with all good faith whatever Supreme Court and Fifth Circuit precedent is binding., He was confirmed in June 2019 by a Republican majority Senate by a vote of 52-46. One by one, the senators quizzed Kacsmaryk on the commentary and legal briefs hed signed in recent years. Separately, Kacsmaryk has twice blocked the Biden administration from quickly ending a Trump-era Remain in Mexico program, which sent asylum seekers back across the border to await decisions on their applications for U.S. protection. Judge Matthew Kacsmaryk hasn't . The delay forced a scramble to try to reach Amarillo in time to be inside the courtroom. Rep. Chip Roy (R-Tex. Their mother, Dorothy, a microbiologist, was particularly passionate about antiabortion issues, Griffith said. More than 150 people recently showed up outside Kacsmaryks courthouse to support access to medication abortion, an unusual show of force for the heavily conservative Texas Panhandle. [22] On February 7, 2019, his nomination was reported out of committee by a 1210 vote. 1:04. A court docket search provides information on ongoing cases, court dates, case summaries, case activities, case numbers, pending cases, decided cases, lawsuits filed with the court, the status of cases, docket numbers, business lawsuits, and individual lawsuits. Women of colour, low-income families, young people, are always over and over again disproportionately harmed by bans on abortion, and a ban on medication abortion would be no exception., Biden criticized for just one mention of abortion in State of the Union speech, Abortion: twenty states threaten to sue CVS and Walgreens over mail-order pills, Original reporting and incisive analysis, direct from the Guardian every morning, 2023 Guardian News & Media Limited or its affiliated companies. Matthew Joseph Kacsmaryk | United States Courts [14], The American Bar Association's Standing Committee on the Federal Judiciary rated Kacsmaryk "qualified" for the federal district bench (this is below the ABA's rating of "well qualified but above its rating of "not qualified"). We will make recommendations for programs that will allow your dad to return to you the man you know him to be and the man God intended him to be, he said. I cant recall an instance when I observed a judge imposing their religion, Kacsmaryk said. Because Amarillo is a federal district with a single judge, plaintiffs know their arguments will be heard by Kacsmaryk who, like any federal judge, is positioned to issue rulings with nationwide implications. Mike Berry, vice president of external affairs at First Liberty, said out-of-state lawyers and plaintiffs will often tell him they want to file a case in Amarillo. Kacsmaryk, the court said, had gone too far in requiring the president to keep in place policies that interfere with his ability to enforce immigration laws and shape foreign policy. Despite assurances of his impartiality, Republican Sen. Susan Collins of Maine joined every voting Democrat in opposition to Kacsmaryk because of his record opposing LGBTQ rights and what she called his extreme statements in opposition to Roe v. Wade. When Kacsmaryk left home at age 18, he drove 2 hours from Fort Worth to Abilene Christian University a deeply conservative campus known for its Bible major and mandatory daily chapel. Date Filed Document Text . [35], Also in 2022, Kacsmaryk vacated protections for transgender workers enacted by the Biden administration, citing Bostock v. Clayton County saying that Title VII "prohibits employers from discriminating against employees for being gay or transgender, "but not necessarily [in the case of] all correlated conduct. This account includes previously unreported details about the nature and strength of his antiabortion convictions. [19] He opposed the Roe v. Wade Supreme Court ruling that had legalized abortion in the United States. The FDAs job is to protect the health, safety and welfare of Americas women and girls, said Blake. Before being plucked out by Trump for the federal bench, he worked as deputy general counsel at the First Liberty Institute, a Christian law firm based in Plano, Texas, which opposes the separation of church and state and propagates anti-LGBTQ legal theories. [13] On January 18, 2018, his nomination was reported out of committee by an 1110 vote. A more recent docket listing may be available from PACER. Oliver et al v. Janta Express Inc. et al - Justia Dockets & Filings Booneville MS 38829. Judge Matthew J. Kacsmaryk Home Judges District Judges Chambers: 806-468-3830 Courtroom Deputy: Victoria Shrewsbury 806-468-3822 Court Reporter: Please call the Amarillo Clerk's Office at 806-468-3800 Chambers Online Help Desk Courtroom Technology 205 SE 5th Avenue, Room 123 Box F-13248 Amarillo, Texas 79101-1559 Courtroom: 1st Floor